Nancy Molnar
Nancy Ann Molnar (née Feenaghty) a beloved wife, mother, grandmother, great-grandmother, sister, and aunt, passed away peacefully in her sleep on June 14, 2025, at the age of 88 in Mahopac, NY.
Nancy was born on November 24, 1936, to Patrick and Sonia Feenaghty at Cumberland Hospital in Brooklyn, NY. She spent her professional life serving with dedication in the Bronx Civil Court system, where she was respected for her steady presence, warmth, and integrity.
On October 31, 1959, Nancy married her beloved husband, John Molnar, and together they built a life rooted in love, family, and deep devotion to each other. She was the proud mother of Michelle Kilkenny and mother-in-law to Barney Kilkenny.
Nancy is survived by her loving daughter Michelle Kilkenny and son-in-law Barney Kilkenny, her adoring grandchildren and their spouses: Brian and Angela Kilkenny, Erin and Kevin Ford, Colleen and Jordan Thoma. She was also the proud and loving great-grandmother to Haley, James, and Sean Murphy.
She also leaves behind her dear siblings Mary Kosik, Patrick Feenaghty Jr., and Thomas Feenaghty, and sadly was predeceased by her brothers John Feenaghty and Dennis Feenaghty.
Nancy played an active and irreplaceable role in helping to raise her grandchildren—a true foundation of love, guidance, and support across generations. Known simply and lovingly as “Grams” by all who were blessed to be in her life, Nancy’s nurturing spirit, heartfelt prayers, wisdom, and strength shaped generations.
A proud and active member of her community, Nancy spent many years selling bingo cards at the local firehouse for the weekly senior center bingo game—always with a warm smile, a quick laugh, and a twinkle in her eye. She was best known and loved for her role there because she let everyone pick their own bingo card, a simple gesture that made people feel seen, lucky, and at home. She will be remembered for her quick wit, generous heart, deep love for her family, and her signature ability to make everyone feel welcome.
The family extends heartfelt thanks for your kind words, support, and prayers during this difficult time. All who knew and loved Nancy are welcome to attend and celebrate her remarkable life.
Visitation will be held Thursday, June 19, 2025 from 3:00pm to 7:00pm at Cargain Funeral Homes, Inc., 418 Route 6 (GPS US-6), Mahopac, NY 109541.
A Mass of Christian Burial to celebrate Nancy’s life will take place at 10:00am on Friday, June 20, 2024 at St. John the Evangelist Church, 221 East Lake Blvd, Mahopac, NY.
Following Mass, Nancy will be escorted to her final resting place alongside her beloved husband John Molnar in Gate of Heaven Cemetery, 10 W Stevens Ave, Hawthorne, NY 10532.
In lieu of flowers, the family kindly requests donations be made to a charity that reminds you of Grams. Suggested organizations include Saint John the Evangelist Church in Mahopac, the William Koehler Memorial Senior Center, the American Heart Association, or the National Kidney Foundation—causes close to her heart.
Funeral arrangements entrusted to Cargain Funeral Homes, Inc., 418 Route 6, Mahopac, NY10541, 845-628-5655, www.cargainfuneralhomes.com.
We at Cargain Funeral Homes, Inc. are deeply committed to responsibly responding to the health, well-being, and needs of the families, guests, and communities we are privileged to serve.